Diaspora Living a Manifestation of Globalization
By Edmond Y. Azadian
For centuries, when Armenians were exiled from their native land, the perception was that life in the diaspora was the destiny of the Armenian people or at best one similar to the plight of the Jews. But the two world wars and the technological advances which ensued made mass mobility a way of life. Different groups which had been forced to abandon their native lands formed their own diasporas and faced different challenges for their survival.
The fall of the Soviet Union added new waves of migrants who moved to the West to add a new layer of diasporan life. But the migrants who had left Armenia for Russia, Ukraine or Central Asia experienced a new derivative of their former lifestyle, because they did not face the challenges of linguistic and cultural barriers that their predecessors had.
Early Armenian settlers in the Middle East or Western countries had suffered tremendously because the life of exile was traumatic for them. Additionally, they had come to their new environment with the baggage of genocide and deportation and they took relocation as a punishment born of the injustice of being uprooted from their ancestral habitat. For the new migrants, the new lands represent new frontiers, new opportunities and the expectation of improved living conditions compared to their original homes.
In the case of the Armenians — unlike Syrians, Iraqis and Libyans — the migration in most cases is on voluntary basis. In other words, there is a tremendous degree of choice compared to their forefathers.
Now that the majority of the Armenians live outside of their homeland, they still relate to that homeland and the majority among them believes their identity is defined by that homeland. Armenia has a vision of the diaspora and vice versa. It is not easy to define where those visions meet or coincide. Therefore, we are in constant quest: what is the diaspora mission and vision? Who represents the diaspora? That latter question particularly is asked when the issue of compensation from Turkey or settlement with that country are raised. Also, the same question is raised when the opportunity arises to speak with the Armenian government.
In recent years, many pundits, scholars and scientists have been writing and discussing the above issues. At times, the subject is the diaspora, but more often it is the global Armenians. Many sensible ideas and theories are being formed and sometimes initiatives are even taken to get organized. The last case had been adopted by a bona fide benefactor, Vahe Karapetian, in California, who has already drafted bylaws for a would-be diasporan organization called “Pan-Armenian Unity.”
Some people who undertake such ambitious projects use specific communities as a model. In this case, the California Armenians shape Mr. Karapetian’s vision, although his goal seems to encompass the entire diaspora.
Global visions for Armenia and the diaspora have been promoted also by Ruben Vardanyan, the Gulbenkian Foundation and many other organizations and individual visionaries.
Whereas independent Armenia’s government is duty-bound to develop its vision or objective projects as to where Armenia and Armenians are envisioned to be 50 years from now, we find now that the new revolutionary government there has decided to eliminate the Ministry of Diaspora without any explanations. There were talks that the Ministry of Diasporan Affairs would be absorbed by another ministry, but nothing has come of it yet.
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s concept for the country’s ties with the diaspora seems to include having an agency which must deal not only with diaspora affairs but also with immigration into the country.
Attempts for earlier mass immigration movements proved to be catastrophic because of a lack of adequate planning. The Soviets had a particular format in mind and they organized the repatriation of Armenians from Middle Eastern countries at a great cost. Today, the target communities for repatriation are mainly Russia, Ukraine and Central Asian countries, where new settlers are not particularly welcome and their ties with the homeland are still fresh.
For other communities, diasporan living has become a function of globalization. They visit Armenia or even set up a part-time residence there but they continue to consider their home base to be in the West.
Whether we like it or not, there is permanence in diasporan living, that is why many people are in search of a goal or goals for that kind of collective existence.
Through a natural process, the diaspora has become fragmented. And it has also lost the kind of leadership it enjoyed in the past. Heroes such as General Antranig commanded tremendous respect and the masses looked to him to provide leadership. That caliber of leadership is non-existent today; today, even if Antranig were resurrected, not many people would heed his advice or his orders.
The diaspora no longer needs leaders who can think for the masses and issue comm
- First "Spider-Man: Far From Home" trailer lands online (video) NEW 0 MINUTES AGO
- Armenian American Museum hosting inaugural Telethon on Feb. 17 NEW 26 MINUTES AGO
- In Yerevan on January 16, 18-20 no precipitation is predicted
- New Year photos of Yerevan on Iranian ILNA website (photo)
- “The Sins of the Fathers” By Siobhan Nash-Marshall to Be Presented in Glendale & Pasadena
- US condemns Iran for satellite launch
- Russia expecting progress in the Karabakh settlement in 2019: Lavrov
- New Mayor of Jerusalem Visited the Armenian Patriarchate
- We will use all legal methods to capture Gülen: Turkish Ministry of Justice
- Georgs Avetisjans: Pursuing His Crane to the Fatherland
- Meeting of Armenian, Azerbaijani FMs begins in Paris
- Pashinyan Formally Reappointed Prime Minister
- Recipe Corner: Garbanzo Bean and Vegetable Soup
- Kim Kardashian restates her wish to visit Armenia with Cher (video)
- New Armenian park to be established near Rostov
- Acting Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan meets with the OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs
- Today is World Beatles Day
- Henrikh Mkhitaryan "can‘t wait" to be back on Arsenal pitch
- Armenian President meets with ALNOWAIS Investments Chairman in Abu Dhabi
- Kurds in the Limelight of the Syrian War Theater
- We and the world around us
- New campaign against the US president?
- In the daytime of January 17 the air temperature will go down by 5-6 degrees
- Pashinyan offers condolences to Iranian president over deadly cargo plane crash
- Romanian TAROM airline enters Armenian market